Study Guide for Tomorrow’s Discussion of “Into Thin Air” by Jon Krakauer
Working for Outside Magazine
Reality of death: Ken Jones
Insights by Dr. Ken Kamler into the Everest disaster. “The Will to Survive”
Intro: Excerpt from Krakauer speech
All: I hope the questions posted on the page helped you: https://www.cbsd.org/cms/lib/PA01916442/Centricity/Domain/1574/Into_Thin_Air_story.pdf
- Why is the lead (first two grafs) more like a conclusion in an ordinary feature?
- Hard question. Did the presence of journalist Jon Krakauer and the female journalist Sandy Pittman ultimately endanger other climbers? How did Sherpa Lopsang Jangbu Sherpa violate his ethical duties by short roping Sandy Pittman to keep her going when she should have turned back?
- What does Beck Weathers conceal that ultimately puts him into danger and slows the progress of his companions?
- Rob Hall was the highly respected king of Everest group leaders. What led to his downfall and death? How did his favoritism for one team member (Doug Hansen) turn into a catastrophe after he violated his own deadline?
- How did the presence of so many ill-led expeditions put the climbers into jeopardy?
- On deadline for Outside, Krakauer makes the reporting mistake of his life. (He acknowledges the error in his later book). He thought guide Andy Harris had fallen off the mountain in the storm. Instead, the guide died trying to save Rob Hall.
- What was wrong with Scott Fischer’s guide Anatoli insisting on climbing without supplemental oxygen?
- The most complex stories you will ever tell as a journalist involve scandals best termed as a fiasco. How could this tragedy have been prevented?
- Discuss the ethics here: Climbers on Everest have a good chance of dying. In fact, the dead are seldom removed from Everest. They greet the climbers. Is this a legitimate and ethical chance for climbers to take?
- Conditional Morality.
Assignment for Tuesday, Sept. 13. Short reading of “Superstar” by Alexandra Robbins.
First draft of your team’s story.
For Thursday, Sept. 15. Read first three chapters of “The Feather Thief.”
Sept. 15. As final a version of your first team story as possible to go to our editors, photo team, writing coaches and social media team.