• Hazing Deaths Database:
  • Blog
  • Storytelling
  • Bio
  • High School Sexual Hazing Incidents
  • Campus Speaker: Hazing & Binge Drinking
  • Hank Nuwer: selected media coverage
  • World Hazing Incidents
  • “Hazing,” “Sons of the Dawn,” “Legend of Jesse Owens”

Hank Nuwer's Hazing Scholarship Site

Follow me on Social Media

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

The FAMU case, redux

August 10, 2008 By Hank Nuwer Leave a Comment

Moderator: Here are a few wise observations by a friend named Dave who has kindly supplied the following comments with regard to the Florida A & M retrial, after the judge was ruled by an appeals court to have erred in not offering the jury a wider definition of injury sustained by the victim in the case, Marcus Jones

A few thoughts on the FAMU case:
  • It is not unusual for there to be some reversals and remands for cases decided under relatively new legislation.  No matter how carefully legislators and others wordsmith and craft statutory language, the real test comes at the trial court level.
  • It appears to me from the articles that the appellate court was very specific in its ruling about the jury instructions.  Instructions are a very valid basis for appeal.  In most criminal cases the instructions have been standardized and published.  Any variation from those is frowned upon and most of the judges I practiced before were very careful to follow the standard instructions. If one side or the other wanted to expand or elaborate upon the instructions, that could be done but only after review beforehand.  It was not clear to me here if there were standardized instructions or if the trial court “Freelanced” with the language.  If she did freelance, then the reversal is understandable.  And, reversals occur with jury instructions because of the significant impact or effect the instructions have upon jurors.
  • As usual, each decision these days prompts a reaction from counsel–the proverbial “Can you can top this?”  While the defense attorneys for the civil cases are correct in noting that a reversal of the criminal cases means that the convictions cannot be used at this time, the plaintiffs certainly have an advantage in terms of case preparation–they now have a lot of evidence, much of the work has been done for them, and they have witnesses on the record (under oath).  The fact that the criminal case was reversed has no effect upon prior testimony under oath being used, especially in cross examination.  I don’t recall if the defendants took the stand in the criminal case, but if they did, that testimony can be used to impeach them at the civil trial.
  • It is my hope that the prosecutor will pursue the cases again.  It is usually easier to obtain a conviction the second time around–witnesses are more comfortable in the courtroom, attorneys know what will be said (in general) and most of the key objections and issues have been decided.

Filed Under: Hazing News

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Inquiries

Hank Nuwer

Correspondence: Hank Nuwer at Hnuwer@hanknuwer.com   Phone number upon request.  Available presentations USA, … Email to book a date.

Sons of the Dawn

Sons of the Dawn: A Basque Odyssey: Hank's novel is for teens 11-18 but also meant to be enjoyed by … Read More

Hazing Deaths Database:

… Read More

Tallahassee police label December FSU fraternity death an accident, not hazing. Deaths involve FSU SAE and Sig Ep.

Here is the story link The death of a popular Florida State University student found unresponsive inside the Sigma Phi Epsilon house in December has been determined accidental, according to an autopsy released late Tuesday. The District Two Medical Examiner’s Office said the death of William Eppes Proctor, 22, was due to “right epidural hematoma due to […]

Pullman Police Chief Jenkins drops the ball in Big-Little death.

The police chief missed the deadline to post hazing charges. Shame on Pullman Police and the Prosecutor for letting the one-year statute of limitations expire in the “Big-Little” death of Sam Martinez, a travesty, at Washington State’s Alpha Tau Omega house. “We had our eyes on a potential more serious offense, that was manslaughter, and […]

Death of a rookie at Lyon College

The bruised body of James Gilfedder is undergoing an autopsy at this time while his teammates continue to play.   Gilfedder’s parents told Arkansas media that their son’s body was battered, and he consumed a fifth of alcohol at a team “hazing party.”  Police are waiting for autopsy results before commenting.  Media said the house […]

Another 2020 close call — TCU

Moderator: This is the same university that had injured pledges in September 2020: https://www.star-telegram.com/news/local/fort-worth/article218683030.html Benton McDonald  -INCIDENT #2.  So similar to death of Nicky Cumberland at University of Texas–Moderator January 28, 2021 TCU placed a fraternity on probation after a hazing investigation revealed that students involved in a car crash last November had been sent […]

Archives


Hank Nuwer's Hazing Scholarship Site is proudly powered by WordPress