Categories
Hazing News

Near Death

KTLA News

January 2, 2009

DAVENPORT — A student from UC Santa Cruz remains hospitalized weeks after he lost consciousness during what police say may have been a fraternity hazing ritual.

Warren Fung, 20, has regained consciousness, but has remained hospitalized since the Dec. 15 incident at Bonny Doon Beach.

It is unclear how long Fung was in the water or on the beach, where about 50 people were gathered as early as 7 a.m. that day, according to Kirk Lingenfelter, State Parks supervisor for the Santa Cruz County coastline.

The Santa Cruz district attorney’s office and park rangers are now investigating whether a crime was committed.

UC Santa Cruz will look into the possible hazing after the State Parks investigation is complete.

Categories
Hazing News

Serious charges at Utah State

USU fraternity, sorority charged with hazing
Alcohol poisoning » 12 students implicated in teen’s death.

By Brian Maffly

The Salt Lake Tribune
Cache County prosecutors on Friday filed felony hazing charges against two Utah State University Greek-letter societies and misdemeanor charges against 12 of their members, including top officers, in connection with the alcohol-poisoning death of an 18-year-old pledge.

In a playful initiation ritual that occurred with past pledges, Michael Starks, a freshman from Salt Lake City, was “captured” by sorority women who painted him and fed him vodka in the company of Sigma Nu fraternity and Chi Omega sorority members, according to charges filed in Logan’s First District Court.

The fun turned deadly for Starks, whom paramedics found unresponsive at the Sigma Nu house at 4 a.m. on Nov. 21. Medical examiners later determined his blood alcohol level reached .373, more than four times the legal limit for driving,

While charging documents indicate Starks was not forced to drink as a prerequisite for joining the fraternity, Utah’s hazing statute allows for conviction even if the victim consented to the abuse, as long he or she is younger than 21. The case highlights the dangers of hard liquor in the hands of an inexperienced drinker, prosecutor Tony Baird said.

“If you beat someone with [a] paddle, make them a slave for a week, that’s hazing. There is no coercion in this case at all,” Baird said. “This is where you have a fraternity that coordinates a capture activity. It’s a have-fun kind of thing. The guys really look forward to it. They want
Advertisement

to be the one chosen.”

Utah’s hazing statute criminalizes behavior that “endangers the mental or physical health or safety of another… for the purpose of initiation, admission into, affiliation with, holding office in, or as a condition of continued membership in any organization.” Hazing is considered a misdemeanor absent aggravating circumstances and the law specifically references liquor consumption. Although hazing becomes a third-degree felony when it results in serious bodily harm, only the organizations’ USU chapters are targeted for felony prosecution.

The students face a year in jail if convicted, while punishment for the chapters is unclear.

The Starks family was “elated” that prosecutors filed felony charges.

“It reflects the seriousness of the situation,” Starks’ father, George, said Friday. “The fraternity has to be held accountable. It’s a system, a machine that envelopes the kids. Any one of those kids could have said, ‘Wait a minute, this isn’t a good thing.'”

Hijinks gone awry

The week before Starks died, Sigma Nu members selected him and another student, 22-year-old Mackenzie Perry, as their top choices among the 16 young men who pledged last fall. At the time, Starks was staying at the fraternity, although he had a dorm room. At about 10 p.m. on Nov. 20, Sigma Nu member Christopher Ammon brought Starks and Perry to the Chi Omega sorority next door under the pretext of helping move furniture. The women took custody of the young men and sorority sister Whitney Miller, who had a liter bottle of vodka, drove Starks to the Logan home of fraternity brother Grant Barney at 181 W. 200 North.

Miller, who faces the most serious charges, told police fraternity members asked her to run the “capture.”

“The only direction given by the fraternity was ‘to not let Mack [Perry] drink too much’ because he is small in stature,” the charges state. “Otherwise, she was not prohibited to use alcohol in the activity.”

The women asked the pledges to strip to their boxers, then painted the naked men Aggie blue and white. The men were given two bottles, Miller’s liter bottle of vodka and a smaller one, which the women held to the pledges’ mouths because their hands were covered in paint, charges allege.

“Eventually, however, Michael took the taller bottle — the vodka — and began to drink it himself,” charging documents state. Perry told Starks to quit drinking, but he was so drunk he could not follow through, Perry told investigators. No charges were filed in connection with Perry’s hazing because he is of legal drinking age.

After an hour, the other Sigma Nu pledges appeared and “rescued” Perry and Starks from Barney’s house and took them back to Sigma Nu, at 765 N. 800 East. Fraternity members put the two drunk pledges in the shower, then to bed. Starks needed help washing, but he was talking and lucid before falling asleep, the charges say.

At some point that night, member Colton Hansen grew concerned about Starks and called poison control, which advised the fraternity brothers to give Starks water, lay him on his side and monitor him. They followed the instructions and two pledges watched over him. At 3:45 a.m., chapter president Cody Littlewood came into the room and discovered Starks wasn’t breathing. Fraternity brother Kelly McGill started CPR, while Littlewood called 911. Paramedics failed to resuscitate Starks, who was later pronounced dead at a hospital.

Police found a fake ID in Starks’ room, indicating his age at over 21. His friends told police that Starks had used it to purchase alcohol in the past and they had seen him drunk the weekend before his death. Starks family members, however, say Michael, the youngest in a close-knit Catholic family of six children, had no prior history of heavy drinking.

Participating in this fraternity initiation rite was required for the Chi Omega sorority pledges, according to Starks’ older brother George Jr., whose family was briefed by prosecutors on Wednesday. “One of the girls was uncomfortable with what was going on and left, and another one was pressured to stay,” George Starks Jr. claimed Friday.

USU officials have already suspended the Sigma Nu and Chi Omega chapters as campus organizations, and the chapters’ national offices have likewise suspended them, pending the outcome of the investigation.

Both organizations publicly maintain zero-tolerance toward hazing and alcohol abuse, and Sigma Nu has co-sponsored research into the cultural phenomenon of hazing and ways to eliminate it. The 250-chapter fraternity was founded in 1868 at Virginia Military Institute in opposition to the physical harassment that young officers endured at the hands of their older colleagues, according to Sigma Nu Executive Director Brad Beacham. Contacted late Friday, both he and Chi Omega’s national executive director Anne Emmerth reserved comment on the Starks case until they read the charges.

“We certainly respect law enforcement’s choice to pursue the criminal charges they feel are warranted and appropriate,” Beacham said. “We will take into account any and all new information as it becomes available.”

University officials were not available for comment Friday.

bmaffly@sltrib.com

Categories
Hazing News

Delaware death

Alcohol suspected in frat pledge’s death

NEWARK, Del. – Authorities are looking into the possibility of an alcohol overdose as part of the investigation of a University of Delaware freshman’s death.

Paramedics were called to a home in Newark just before 3 a.m. yesterday and found Brett Griffin, 18, of Kendall Park, N.J., in cardiac arrest and not breathing.

He was taken to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead a short time later.

Police say Griffin was a pledge of the Sigma Alpha Mu fraternity and was attending a function at the fraternity house. About 40 people were at the house at the time.

Police say that while an overdose of alcohol is being considered as the preliminary cause of the medical emergency, an autopsy will be performed, most likely today.

– Associated Press

Newark, Delaware – Griffin Update Autopsy

By admin • Dec 4th, 2008 • Category: NewsDISCLAIMER – Any Charges Reported in these Press Releases are Merely Accusations and the Defendants are Presumed Innocent Unless and Until Proven Guilty.
Email Story Link

Police Department Press Release

December 4, 2008 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE SUBJECT: Brett Griffin Update The Newark Police Department has been made aware of the results of the autopsy performed on Brett Griffin, the University of Delaware student who died on November 8. State law prohibits the Newark Police Department from disclosing information contained in the autopsy report. The Newark Police Department’s investigation into the events surrounding Mr. Griffin’s death is still active and remains on-going. Since the case is still being actively investigated, it is premature to comment on any findings to date or the potential final results.

Anyone with information pertinent to the investigation is encouraged to contact Det. Andrew Rubin at 302-366-7110 ext 135 or Andrew.Rubin@cj.state.de.us. Further information will be disseminated as it becomes available. There is no schedule for the next release of information.

Media Contact: Lt. Brian Henry, Public Information Officer 302-366-7110 ext. 125 or
Brian.Henry@cj.state.de.us

Categories
Hazing News

Washington death

By Maks Goldenshteyn
June 23, 2008
ShareThis

Kevin MacDonald, a 21-year-old University of Washington student, died the morning of June 14 after falling headfirst out of his third-story bedroom window. He fell onto the concrete surface below the house of Alpha Sigma Phi fraternity, where he was a member.

MacDonald was not seen at the house the evening before and had been asleep in his room for some time before the accident, said Owen McCulloch, president of Alpha Sigma Phi national fraternity.

Police and fraternity officials suspect that MacDonald, a junior psychology major, was alone and getting in or out of his bed when he fell from his window at approximately 4:30 a.m.

Emergency personnel were called to the scene shortly after the fall, which awakened those inside the fraternity house, located at 4554 19th Ave. N.E.

MacDonald was rushed to Harborview Medical Center, where he died that evening. About 20 of MacDonald’s fraternity brothers had visited him at the hospital earlier.

“The impact of this incident is overwhelming,” said Eliab Sisay, the fraternity’s UW chapter president. “I just can’t find the words to express the sadness I and the entire chapter feel.”

Witnesses said that no parties had been held inside the house during the hours leading up to the fall, according to Seattle Police Department (SPD) spokesman Mark Jamieson.

People in the house told officers they had seen the victim before the accident and that he had been drinking, Jamieson said.

MacDonald had apparently been seen away from the house at a party, but it is too early to tell what role alcohol played in the tragedy.

“What ultimately killed him was the fall and landing on his head,” Jamieson said.

When asked if officials from Alpha Sigma Phi plan to investigate the accident, McCulloch, the national fraternity president, said, “All of the actions of the national fraternity are in supporting Mr. MacDonald’s family and friends and the members of our University of Washington chapter.”

Eric Godfrey, the UW vice provost for student life, said the UW Police Department is “standing at the ready” in the investigation and that the school is “very deeply involved” in helping those affected by the tragedy.

Godfrey said both he and UW President Mark Emmert plan to speak to the families of the fraternity members. Mental health counseling is available to the Alpha Sigma Phi brothers, Godfrey said.

Funeral services were held last Friday in Kent, Wash., where MacDonald grew up.

MacDonald’s fraternity brothers hosted a candlelight vigil Thursday in front of the house. Members of the UW and Greek communities, and MacDonald’s parents and family and friends signed a memorial canvas with personal remembrances.

The UW chapter of Alpha Sigma Phi is working with MacDonald’s family to establish an endowment in his name, McCulloch said.

“It is a very difficult time for all concerned, and our thoughts and prayers are with the MacDonald family and friends,” he said.

Categories
Hazing News

Northern Arizona Pike chapter booted, student paper reports

Suspended fraternity used rotten fruit, dry ice in initiation activities
In their list of hazing charges that resulted in a five-year suspension,
NAU officials say Pi Kappa Alpha made pledges eat rotten fruit and
‘branded’ them with dry ice.

By LAURA CLYMER
City Editor

Initiation activities that included pelting pledges with rotten food,
having them strip down to their boxers and spend hours crammed in a
bathroom together, and ‘branding’ them with dry ice were among hazing
incidents that led Northern Arizona University officials to suspend the
largest campus fraternity earlier this month for five years.

Documents released to the the Daily Sun Friday detail the incidents
university officials investigated and used in determining the Theta Rho
Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity was in violation of the Student Code
of Conduct and the University Hazing Prevention Policy.

Pi Kappa Alpha officers have the right to request a hearing on the
suspension and must do so by Jan. 7, 2009. As of Friday, they have yet to
request a hearing nor have they waived rights to a hearing.

The suspension, if upheld, is effective for five years.

In a letter to NAU Student Life officials addressing the hazing
allegations, the Theta Rho chapter of the fraternity stated the incidents
were “a case of misplaced judgment” and not a case of “malice or cruelty.”

The letter dated Nov. 19 stated, “Unfortunately, the oral traditions passed
down from alumni and nationally covering hazing incidents have led us to
conclude that our pledging activities were within the acceptable range.”
The letter also contended that allegations described “have a basis in fact
but have been exaggerated upon.”

NAU defines hazing as an act that “contributes to a substantial risk of
potential physical injury, mental harm or degradation or causes physical
injury, mental harm or personal degradation.”

Student Life officials found the fraternity in violation of four provisions
of the Student Code of Conduct.

PILLOWCASES AND PORN

The alleged hazing occurred during the fall 2007 and spring 2008 semesters
and revolved around a series of pre-initiation events and initiation week
events.

The following summarizes the main accusations and the fraternity’s
response, according the findings of the NAU Office of Student Life and the
letter written by the chapter:

–Blindfolding and placing pillowcases over the heads of pledges and
transporting to undisclosed locations in the bed of a truck.

Response: “… pledges are asked to put pillowcases over the heads to keep
the location undisclosed. During the entire event transportation speeds
were road appropriate for college students.”

–Creating a scavenger hunt activity using glow sticks and pelting pledges
with rotten fruit and vegetables.

Response: “This event is designed as a high intensity game of Capture the
Flag. Pledges were provided protective guys goggles.”

–Forcing blindfolded pledges to stand in a circular structure in the woods
until 5 a.m. and answer questions about the fraternity and their dedication
to it.

Response: “From start to finish this took four to five hours and pledges
never appeared to be mentally or physically distraught after this event.”

–Forcing pledges to “dress down” to their boxer shorts and the “dress up”
into their clothes.

Response: “Pledges were instructed to dress up and dress down.”

–Placing the entire pledge class for an extended amount of time into a
bathroom where pornographic material was posted and strobe lights were used.

Response: The majority of the pledge class was placed in a 72 square-foot
bathroom for two hours. There was pornographic material but it wasn’t
posted and it belonged to the house tenants.

–Requiring pledges to rub lubricant all over their bodies and flex their
muscles for active members.

Response: Pledges were asked to smear Crisco over their bodies for a
“flex-off” competition.

–Sleep deprivation.

Response: The activities didn’t last all night or pledges went to sleep by
3 a.m.

–Forcing pledges to eat breakfast made of rotten food.

Response: Breakfast consisted of “spaghetti-o’s, Hormel chili, Spam, Green
Chilies [sic], Tang, olives, whole beets and Limburger cheese (which gave
off a distinct smell) topped with Fruit Loops. Everything was either fresh
or canned.”

–Forcing pledges to eat a plate of jalapenos and drink a gallon of milk,
causing most of them to vomit.

Response: “Trash cans were present to create a healthy and non-contaminated
environment in case someone got sick.”

–“Branding” the buttocks of pledges with dry ice.

Response: Intended to be a spoof, the dry ice was placed on the skin for
three seconds.

Allegations of offering pledges excessive amount of alcohol, steroid use
among the active members and requesting pledges to find “women” for active
members were unsubstantiated, according to Student Life documents.

In his Dec. 2 letter to the chapter’s officers, NAU Dean of Students Rick
Brandel notes “by their own admission, the Theta Rho Chapter of Pi Kappa
Alpha Fraternity did in fact violate” the university’s student conduct code
and hazing prevention policy and fraternity’s national policies. That
“admission” was the chapter’s Nov. 19 response letter to university officials.

Four violations of the NAU Student Code of Conduct

1. Endangering, threatening or causing physical harm to any member or
causing reasonable apprehension of such harm, or engaging in conduct that a
reasonable would interpret of intent to harm;

2. Violation of rules adopted by the Arizona Board of Regents or the
university;

3. Off-campus conduct that a reasonable person would believe may present a
risk or danger;

4. Engaging in, supporting, promoting or sponsoring hazing, which is an act
that contributes to a substantial risk of potential physical injury, mental
harm or degradation or causes physical injury, mental harm or personal
degradation.

WHAT’S NEXT?

The Theta Rho Chapter of Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity was officially suspended
by NAU Dec. 2.

The incidents could still result in individual members being charged with
violations of the Student Code of Conduct.

If the fraternity files for a hearing, a board made up of two students, two
faculty members and one staff member will convene within a reasonable time.

According to university officials, hearing boards have two primary
responsibilities: to determine if a violation of the Student Code of
Conduct took place, and to make a recommendation regarding the sanction
that should apply, if any.

Pi Kappa Alpha has 86 members and is NAU’s largest fraternity chapter.
Twenty-three members and six pledges were living in Mountain View Residence
Hall, a dorm designated for NAU’s fraternities and sororities. Five
uninitiated members of the fraternity will move to other campus housing.
Three, possibly four, initiated members will move to another campus
residence hall as well.

NAU will work with the remaining active members to find alternative
on-campus housing or allow them to cancel their on- campus housing contract.

© Copyright 2008, The Arizona Daily Sun.